Wrapping It Up: The Struggle To Explain Why Difference Makes a Difference (Sotomayor And The Value of Diversity, The Final Installment)

In my prior post on this topic, What
Corporate Insiders Say About Why Diversity Matters
, I noted that (though
our work is still preliminary) our research suggests that corporate insiders
appear not to have arrived at a master narrative to explain the pursuit of
diversity on boards of directors. Instead, their accounts stress a variety of
factors and feature few concrete examples.  Elements of each of the diversity rationales discussed in my
post, Money Is Diversity or Diversity Is Money?,
appear, but it is largely a theoretical narrative without concrete detail — a
story without substance.  When
invited to elaborate, subjects have digressed into instances that had little to
do with race or gender, and in fact have often distanced themselves from
demographic variables.  And none
expressed anything more than a hope that diversity would correlate with
business performance.  Despite
their focus on the business case for diversity, overall our subjects do not
tell that story concretely or consistently, instead falling back on a story
that is more similar to “it seems like a good thing to do.”

And, indeed, it may be.  As noted, the empirical research on board diversity presents
methodological
hurdles
and conflicting results, leaving many questions unanswered.  Accordingly, there’s no empirical
consensus on whether board diversity improves firm performance.  All we can say is that, if there is a
business case to be made for board diversity, most of our respondents do not
make that case with much specificity.

And perhaps this should not be entirely surprising.  After all, I began
this series of posts
by lamenting the lack of specificity and rigor in most
discussions, prompted by the Sotomayor nomination, about the possible role of diversity
on the Supreme Court.   And that is a much more familiar
institution to most than the corporate boardroom.  Moreover, some diversity rationales – for example, fairness,
representational, and social good rationales — that feature prominently in discussions
of diversity’s benefits in public, educational, or political institutions are
more problematic
, both practically and theoretically, in the corporate board
context.

In closing, a striking summary of boardroom discussions
about board diversity came from a white female director with significant
experience providing professional advice to corporate boards. The specific
question posed was why one particular board had sought diversity. Her account
suggests that the business world does not have a well-reasoned board diversity
rationale—in fact, in her view, the question of rationale is never even
discussed:

I suspect you haven’t gotten many introspective answers on
that because, in fact, you’re never going to have a board that will honestly
question whether or not there is a value associated with that.  And people will accept it and move
on.  Everybody says the same thing
because, again, I’m in boardrooms a hundred times a year and I hear the same
discussion.  And what they say is
we have skill sets that we want and if we can find a diverse candidate who
fulfills them without sacrificing the skill sets that we’re looking for that
would be terrific.  And the
analysis doesn’t go any further. 
It just isn’t discussed.  So
anything I tell you about why I think diversity adds value is going to be [my]
thoughts because it was not a topic of discussion.  [Sentence that identifies company deleted.]  So to the extent we’re talking about
sort of that wide swath of middle America, then it’s nice to have a board that
is in some respects emblematic of that but we’ve never discussed it.

That concludes my posts in this series.  Thanks for reading, and don’t forget to
also read our papers (here and here) on
board diversity, which include a much more extensive use of the interview
transcripts.  And send us feedback
and comments – despite the work we’ve already done, we still have years of work
ahead of us.  As a way of saying
“thanks” for your attention so far, I leave you with this wholly unrelated, but
funny, clip on “Diversity Day” from The Office.

To read my prior posts in this series see:
I.                   
Sotomayor, Diversity, And Group Dynamics: Why
Do We Care? What Do We Know?



II.                 
Do The Right Thing, So Long As It’s Free

III.               
Money Is Diversity or Diversity Is Money?
IV.                
What
Corporate Insiders Say About Why Diversity Matters

2 Comments

  1. Ediberto Roman

    An interesting group of posts. They raise important issues, especially for those that teach in the corporate area and contend with soft legal concepts such as social responsibilty. In light of these writings, I would ask the authors what value, if any, they would place on board dversity. Perhaps that was not the goal of this research or the posts for that matter. However, this reader is nonetheless left wondering what would be authors exhaustive answer to this issue.

    Ediberto Roman

  2. Kim Krawiec

    Thanks for your comment, Ediberto. You’re correct that the project is designed as a purely descriptive ethnographic one – what do corporate insiders say about whether board diversity is important and, if so, why? And then, secondarily, to illuminate logical or internal inconsistencies in those narratives. So the project wasn’t designed to answer the bottom-line question of whether board diversity adds value and, in fact, can’t answer it.

    Having said that, I think that our next paper will touch on at least two counterexamples to the story of incoherence that we put forward in the first paper. Those two relate to the role that a diverse board may play in (1) diversifying the senior management pool when determining issues of succession, and (2) recruiting, training, and retaining women and minorities in management, including lower-level management.

    We did not see these counterexamples with all diverse boards. Not all female or minority directors mentioned these as issues of interest, whereas others were clearly quite committed. Moreover, it takes more than one director to make a difference here – it takes other willing board members and, with respect to item (2) above, a willing CEO as well. So we don’t see this across the board, but we saw it enough to be interesting, I think.

    I should add that, even if it is true that diverse boards perform these functions better than nondiverse ones, the respondents’ claims that this is good for business are themselves contested claims. But at least now we’re talking about redistributing opportunities on a broad scale – you can imagine that at least some people would consider this a worthy goal, even in the absence of a bottom-line profit impact.

    So I hope that our next paper will provide further insight. Best, Kim

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *