One would be challenged to find an academic without an opinion on Judge Amy Coney Barrett's impending nomination to replace Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg. On Saturday morning Politico Magazine featured the views from several leading constitutionalists on the pick. As one might imagine, the range of views was great.
Dean Tomiko Brown-Nagin observed, "If confirmed, Judge Amy Coney Barrett will consolidate the conservative majority and shift the balance of power on the court decidedly to the right."
Professor Saikrishna Prakash wrote, "Judge Amy Coney Barrett has all the qualities of a first-class Supreme Court justice: intellect, wisdom, temperament and restraint."
As one might imagine, those leaning right would champion the pick, and several did: Ilya Shapiro noted, "Judge Amy Coney Barrett has displayed a seriousness of purpose and is dedicated to finding and applying the Constitution’s original public meaning. Her thoughtful opinions and academic writings show a willingness to hold government officials’ feet to the constitutional fire. But for those on the left, the nomination was reason for concern as Chancellor Howard Gillman observed, With the appointment of Amy Coney Barrett — an undoubtedly qualified jurist with rock-solid conservative credentials — the court will revert to the role it performed for most of our history, with an ironclad majority of conservative justices who have dedicated their careers to taking back the courts....In short, once again, the court will be a conservative bulwark against democratic forces."
I had the great honor to be included in this group of luminaries, and finished my assessment with the following, "As I write these words, I am watching my 10-year-old on her computer studying American history, and I can’t help but wonder how much my Bella will be inspired by our recently passed icon and how much she will learn of the battles the “Notorious RBG” fought for her. How different equality may look like in a world led by those who appear to reject it — the epitome of being selectively principled."
Recent Comments