Search the Lounge


« Harv. J. L. & Gender Accepting Submissions | Main | Weidemaier: Dear NY Times: Thank You For Letting Me Sue Only 500 Miles From My Home »

November 01, 2015


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Lisa Lerman

I also suffer from chronic illness, previously diagnosed as fibromyalgia, an amorphous sibling of CFS, but in the last year it has become clear to me that my illness is caused by exposure to toxins produced by mold. It is not an allergy. Some call it toxic mold illness, some call it chronic inflammatory response syndrome. Most of the thousands who suffer from this illness were previously diagnosed with CFS or with fibromyalgia. i agree with Steve that there is a growing mass of people who have these chronic illnesses, and that there are many in legal education, teachers, staff and students, who are affected. We need to overcome the stigma and talk about it, for the sake of our collective health, and because people suffering from chronic illness need lawyers and academics as advocates.

Steve L

Brava, Lisa!

Carole carrick

At 16 mins, speaking about the PACE trial, Simon Wessely says: "It was the "final, kind of, definitive trial... I'm not connected with this trial. I recruited some patients for it but I was not part of it... I wish I had been...because it's a genuinely beautiful trial. It's one of the most beautiful behavioural medicine trials that we've ever seen... So, it's a fantastic and beautiful trial... We've improved the physical health, the psychological health, functioning and so on of a large number of people... It's also incredibly safe despite some of the things that's been said about it... these are very, very, safe treatments."

Barbara B. Comerford

As a practicing disability attorney who was diagnosed with CFS/ME, now also known as SEID, in the late 1980s, I have successfully represented hundreds of individuals with this illness. I have also sat on a number of CFS Boards including the CFIDS Association of America, the AACFS (now the IACFS), the NJCFSA and I was also a co-author on the first Physician Consensus Manual on CFS which was funded by the New Jersey Academy of Sciences, the New Jersey Department of Health & Human Services, and the University of Medicine and Dentistry of New Jersey. It has taken forever but NIH recently announced that ME/CFS will be moved from Women's Health (with paltry research funds available) to the National Institute for Neurological Diseases and Strokes with increased research funds promised. The government has moved at a snail's pace with respect to this illness but, thankfully, it is moving in a positive direction. Over the years I have learned for an individual suffering with these symptoms to have a fighting chance of success against the insurance industry and the government, they need to be treated by physicians who truly understand CFS/ME, believe in it, and are familiar with the diagnostic criteria, and recent scientific advances in testing for symptom validity. Well meaning physicians who take the "throw down your crutches and walk" approach do not understand the illness or the debilitating physical and psychological consequences to the patient of such suggestions. Fortunately today there are skilled, respected providers including physicians, researchers and others who can document many of the more challenging symptoms such as fatigue and brain fog. There are neuropsychologists who can test CFS/ME patients and document the specific cognitive dysfunction found in CFS patients including issues with speed of processing, multi-tasking and working memory. There are also specialists who conduct Cardiopulmonary exercise testing which is a two day brief exercise test that measures physical responses to nominal exercise efforts in a 2 day period and can be used to document PEM. And of course there are other CFS treating physicians, including Board certified infectious disease specialists, internists, neurologists and others who have dedicated their lives and research efforts to this illness. These cases can be won, but require understanding, education and careful case preparation. I was heartened by your post and agree that many professionals (I've represented hundreds including doctors, lawyers, judges, and captains of industry) are ashamed to publicly admit this illness because the misinformation out there creates a stigma.

Thomas M.

The results of the PACE trial have been spun in both lay and professional media to vastly overstate the supposed efficacy of CBT and GET, and more recently, in Lancet Psychiatry, to obfuscate the follow-up data showing these therapies to be no more effective than the basic medical care received by the control arm of the trial.

This lack of objectivity in press coverage can be traced back, in many instances, to the work of the UK Science Media Centre, which has briefed journalists prior to each new paper with highly partisan "expert opinion" drawn exclusively from academic supporters of CBT and GET.

The absence of dissenting voices from these briefings skews subsequent coverage such that even PACE's null result has been reported as evidence of the long-term efficacy of CBT and GET.

The comments to this entry are closed.


  • StatCounter
Blog powered by Typepad