Celebrity Drug Habits: Public or Private?

With thanks as usual to Patricia Sanchez Abril for drawing this case to my attention, I was intrigued by a small issue when reading the 2004 British House of Lords decision in the Naomi Campbell case.  This case involved the unauthorized publication by the Mirror newspaper of details of Campbell's drug problems.  The case is interesting in itself as a discussion of the then relatively new task of British courts to balance free speech and privacy interests recently revised in British law under the Human Rights Act of 1998.

What particularly interested me about the case, though, was the concession made by all parties that the British newspaper had a right to publish a story confirming that Campbell had drug problems, despite her previous public protestations to the contrary.  The case then focused on the extent to which particular details about her treatment should be protected as confidential. 

I am interested in the rationale supporting the concession that the paper had the right to publish the fact of the drug addiction effectively under the auspices of "public interest".  The reasoning was that the media had this right because Campbell had publicly denied having a drug addiction in the past and had favorably compared herself to other models who did have such problems  - assertions that turned out not to be true.  It was suggested by several of the judges that if Campbell had not made these public comments, the fact of her drug addiction might have been properly protected as confidential, but that, given her comments, the Mirror was justified in running a story to tell the public that her comments were untrue.  (The question for the court was how much latitude the paper should have with respect to details and photographs of her specific treatment.)

My question is whether it is necessarily appropriate to say that someone effectively loses the right to privacy or confidentiality because they have represented that they do not have a personal and sensitive problem that in fact they do have?  What are they expected to do when asked by the press whether they have a drug habit?  Does society really expect such people to tell the truth publicly on such a sensitive issue?  And do we feel differently about these questions depending on whether the subject of the disclosure is a celebrity versus some other public figure like a politician?  In other words, would we be more concerned that someone with governmental responsibilities may be impaired by a drug problem than someone whose career is in the entertainment field and whose problems do not have the potential to put important political decisions at risk?

I'm not sure that I know the answers to any of these questions, but I'd be interested in what other people think.  And I do acknowledge that the different laws in England and the United States may well lead to different thoughts on these questions.  For example, in the United States with the longstanding First Amendment speech guarantees, people may have very different perspectives than in England where the notion of a free speech/free press right is a relatively new thing.

Comments

[prescription drug abuse]

Drug addiction is a condition characterized by an overwhelming desire to continue taking a drug to which one has become habituated through repeated consumption because it produces a particular effect, usually an alteration of mental status. Addiction is usually accompanied by a compulsion to obtain the drug, a tendency to increase the dose, a psychologic or physical dependence, and detrimental consequences for the individual and society.

-jomie-

[The Good Drugs Guide to Drug Abuse]

Hard to say, but doesn't seem they should lose their rights to privacy. Very public celebrity drug addicts are nothing new, but then drug addiction is clearly a private issue.

[Andrew Morales]

Hi,

Thanks for writing such a great article. It’s really good to know about drug rehab in such a detail. It all begins with the idea to try how it feels when you take a sip of alcohol. It was not only depends a mouthful, so that increases the desire of some of the drink. And that is how we become dependent, and soon will need Alcohol Detox and rehabilitation.

People like the use of alcohol as a fashion and show their position in principle and is now a drug for them. Sad is that some are not able to achieve. But some are not able or their bad habit or you decide not able to stop what they do with themselves. People who have an addiction to alcohol can do Alcohol Detox. And place that can facilitate the Addiction Treatment is Treatment Solutions Network or www.treatmentsolutionsnetwork.com. By doing Alcohol Detox, alcohol addicts will understand how to overcome the desire to drink alcohol again. And with the desire to recover, usually will accelerate recovery for the patient’s own self. In addition, Opiate Detox can also be done to remove toxins from the body, this can be done if the patient has both alcohol and drugs dependence.

Thanks,

- Andrew Morales

[Sarah Clark]

Hi,

Thanks for writing such a great article. It’s really good to know about drugs and pharmacy in such a detail. Today, there is an easy way to get treatment for the disease. No need to walk through your home in order to buy medicine at the local pharmacy. All you have to do is simply surfing the internet for drugs and on-line. EPharmacies.com portal is the right site to get your drugs on-line. This site is a network of Pharmacies where you are able to aim for cheaper prescription drugs. Now it’s time to stop paying for expensive prescription drugs and get the discount pharmacy.

When you buy drugs on this site, you’ll always get the prices of medicines that suit your budget and looking for the medicine is really exciting. You are able to use the search box in their site to find the products you need to buy just for a short period of time. All online pharmacy in the network has been certified.

Thanks,

Sarah Clark

[kelly]

all are welcome to our meetings on the beach in newport beach ca. http://www.soberliving.com

[san diego sober living]

privacy should still be exercised, whether if its a celebrity or not.

[viagra online]

People like the use of alcohol as a fashion and show their position in principle and is now a drug for them. Sad is that some are not able to achieve. But some are not able or their bad habit or you decide not able to stop what they do with themselves. People who have an addiction to alcohol can do Alcohol Detox. And place that can facilitate the Addiction Treatment is Treatment Solutions Network or www.treatmentsolutionsnetwork.com. By doing Alcohol Detox, alcohol addicts will understand how to overcome the desire to drink alcohol again. And with the desire to recover, usually will accelerate recovery for the patient’s own self. In addition, Opiate Detox can also be done to remove toxins from the body, this can be done if the patient has both alcohol and drugs dependence.